Baldur's Gate 3's Endings Split Gamers

Baldur's Gate 3 Spoilers below.

If there is a place Baldur's Gate 3 Refuses to give the players an easy way out, that's the end of it. Players are dealing with everything at once: the Netherbrain, friends, romances, sacrifices, and what appears to be “victory”.

A Reddit thread asked players to share their “best ending”. Baldur's Gate 3 Quickly turns into a revealing case study. There isn't one. And with so many variables, it's easy to disagree on the small details of perfection. There must be hundreds of slightly different versions of the “ideal”, each shaped by what the player values most during that particular playthrough. Be it freedom, sacrifice, loyalty or keeping your loved ones alive and happy.

Wyll, Gale, Shadowheart, Astarion, and Lae'zel in the Baldur's Gate 3 cover art

related to

Baldur's Gate 3: Best Original Characters for 1st Playthroughs, Ranked

Each Baldur's Gate 3 Origin Character has its positive aspects, but some are better suited to the early game than others.

Is there such a thing as a “perfect ending” in Baldur's Gate 3?

Before discussing any possible ending, it is important to note that even the best endings BG3 Don't fix everything. The responses in the thread above reflect that reality. Someone will always miss something, or a long-term experience can leave a bad taste.

Guess the games from emojis.

Easy (120 seconds) Medium (90 seconds) Hard (60 seconds)

Players can agree on what can be learned as a “good” outcome. The paths there are rarely simple, and the results are not universally satisfactory. This is especially true in games where different playstyles are rewarded. A more heroic race may prioritize sacrifice and moral clarity, while choices in an evil race Baldur's Gate 3 Let a player commit real atrocities.

The mind flayer choice is a huge divider for Baldur's Gate 3 players

A decision that sparks a lot of debate is becoming a mind flayer Baldur's Gate 3. It's the game's most inescapable moral contract, and players approach it in wildly different ways. In the game, the burden can be pushed on Orpheus or himself.

Some players treat the decision like a sacrifice. Reddit user Rugrin describes himself becoming a mind flayer and then banishing his character to Avernus along with Wyll and Karlach: a version of the ending that for some players feels more like penance than victory. But there is no consensus here, only different interpretations of what the right sacrifice looks like.

How players can handle the mind flare option

related to

Why a Baldur's Gate 3 death still hits hard a year later

Baldur's Gate 3 features many heartbreaking moments, but one character's fate remains particularly tragic, even with player intervention.

For Baldur's Gate 3 players, companion outcomes are as important as final battles.

What is remarkable about these discussions is how little attention is paid to the netherbrain itself. The real debate is at the center Baldur's Gate 3Who's original friends: who gets closure, who gets freedom, and who gets left in a bad place.

Players are obviously building their endings around these results. Reddit user Dude_tamale outlines a version where almost every friend gets a hopeful resolution: “Wyll goes to Avernus with Karlach, Gale isn't power hungry, Shadowheart's parents are still alive, Astarion is a spawn (someone give this guy a parasol), convince Lae'zel to stay instead of blindly following him.”

Even with these relatively positive endings, some players have options that they consider better. For example, Reddit user HardlyHilarious provides mostly similar results for friends, except for Lae'zel, Wyll, and Karlach.

The ending of the “good” friend in Baldur's Gate 3 can still divide players

Some characters may have endings that are morally complex. For example, there are black and white moral dilemmas when deciding between a Spawn or an Ascended Astarian. Same goes for Shadowheart. However, Lae'zel, Karlach, and Wyll are a bit more nuanced.

Liesel can lead Githanki to civil war, or she can make her own way to Ferun. BG3The Gith conflict.
Wyll could become the new Grand Duke of Baldur's Gate, the Ravenguard, or the Blade of Avernus.
Karlach can return to Avernus, but only if the player or Wyll joins him. At the end of Karlach BG3 are slightly more controversial, especially because they involve a choice in which she becomes an alithid by choice. Although seemingly negative, this choice is made with his consent and also prevents him from dying from a malfunctioning inferno engine.

Baldur's Gate 3 has no perfect ending, only trade-offs

When it comes to branch ending RPGs, BG3 Gold takes over because of how different the two playthroughs can look from each other. But something does Baldur's Gate 3' What stands out is that its endings feel decisive because they are deeply personal. With no universally accepted best path and few moral choices being side moves rather than righteous, the collection of results reflects player preferences, relationships, and choices over 100+ hours.

Even a relatively small Reddit thread can produce wildly different answers to the same question. Everyone played a slightly different game, and everyone made a slightly different story. And when the credits rolled, everyone walked away with a different version of what looked like “victory.”