Many great TV shows impress audiences, earn a dedicated following, and serve as an influence for later TV series, but it’s always much more noteworthy when a show achieves all of that after only airing a single season. The popularity and influence of hits like Freaks and Geeks and Fox’s Firefly lasted far longer than the series themselves, especially considering the former gave many Hollywood stars their start in the late nineties and early aughts.
One of the unfortunate truths about television is that, despite how well a series is received, these projects don’t always last as long as they should. Sometimes, a TV show doesn’t quite perform as well as studios hope, while other times, a studio will cancel a show before they have time to find their audience. Of course, there’s always the possibility of them returning in one way or another, like a reboot, but it’s rare and never guaranteed. That said, just because an elite show is canceled after only one installment shouldn’t dismiss it from anyone’s watchlist.
7
Police Squad!
1982 – 6 Episodes
Leslie Nielsen may have started as a dramatic actor, but he gained recognition for his deadpan comedy. Most fans know Nielsen as Lieutenant Frank Drebin in the Naked Gun franchise, which began in 1988. However, not everyone remembers that the acclaimed actor actually landed that role six years prior in the television series Police Squad! It was created by David and Jerry Zucker and Jim Abrahams, who’d previously created Airplane!, which also co-starred Nielsen as Dr. Rumack. In all eight episodes, Police Squad! follows Nielsen playing the straight-man detective, investigating a new absurd mystery in each installment. Like Airplane! and the franchise it preceded, Police Squad! is a laugh-a-minute riot with jokes packed into every scene.
“It required constant viewing, and I don’t think that people can watch a TV series without some distractions.” — Anthony Thomopoulos
Unfortunately, while this strategy may have given Airplane! its success, NBC’s executives felt that the show was too dense with jokes for the general audience to keep up with. Fans could argue that this gave them a great reason to tune back in for episode reruns, but the theory led to the untimely cancellation of Police Squad!, according to Nielsen in the DVD commentary. Fortunately, the Zucker brothers and Abrahams stayed the course and released Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad!, which opened the door for the original Nielsen-led trilogy and the laugh-a-minute 2025 reboot starring Liam Neeson.
6
Firefly
2002 – 14 Episodes
Firefly is always mentioned among great shows that were canceled after a single season. The sci-fi Western followed the adventures of Captain Malcolm “Mal” Reynolds (Nathan Fillion) and his crew aboard the Serenity. Firefly only lasted 14 episodes but earned a dedicated following as a unique, postmodern series, filled with its own slang and impressive performances. Aside from Fillion, the show also featured Alan Tudyk as Hoban Washburn, Serenity’s pilot, and Morena Baccarin in her first television role as Inara Serra, although many might know her better as Vanessa from the Deadpool movie franchise.
Though viewers might question why any network would cancel Firefly, many factors contributed to its demise. Of the most prominent, Fox mis-marketed it as a comedy, with Smash Mouth’s “Walking on the Sun“ playing behind TV promos. The network also placed Firefly on the Friday night lineup, putting it against powerhouse shows like American Idol and Joe Millionaire, and aired its episodes out of order. Of course, Firefly found success, albeit after its cancelation, which has inspired talks of an animated reboot with most of the original cast attached to reprise their roles.
5
Freaks and Geeks
1999 – 18 Episodes
In the lexicon of iconic one-season wonders and coming-of-age shows, Freaks and Geeks sits high in the ranks. Created by acclaimed director Paul Feig and produced by Judd Apatow, the teen dramedy launched the careers of several well-known actors. In its cast were names like Seth Rogen, Linda Cardellini, Jason Segel, and Busy Phillips, all starring as 1980s teens navigating high school and adolescence. In its 18 episodes, Freaks and Geeks tackles relatable topics like drugs, sex, relationships, and puberty from the perspective of two cliques: the freaks, led by Daniel Desario (James Franco), and the self-explanatory geeks, who are anchored by Sam Weir (John Francis Daley).
Like other cult television hits, Freaks and Geeks was plagued with problems that outweighed whatever success it had. During its original run, Freaks and Geeks faced an erratic schedule, with only 10 episodes airing sporadically and weeks apart. To make matters worse, when Freaks and Geeks did air, it was on Saturdays at 8 p.m., placing it in a difficult timeslot for its intended audience and up against Who Wants to Be a Millionaire, which dominated the airwaves at the time. The subsequent ratings, and a change in executive leadership, led NBC to unjustly cancel Freaks and Geeks just over a year after it premiered. While MTV offered to pick up Freaks and Geeks for a second season, it was at a lower budget, which Apatow felt wouldn’t have done the show justice.
4
Lovecraft Country
2020 – 10 Episodes
While many great video games are based on H.P. Lovecraft’s works, it’s rare that horror movie and television audiences are gifted with something directly pulled from the author’s novels. When HBO greenlit Lovecraft Country, it aimed to deliver Lovecraftian Horror with the backing of Jordan Peele’s Monkeypaw Productions and J.J. Abrams’ Bad Robot. The show followed Atticus Freeman (Jonathan Majors) as he searches for his missing father with the help of his uncle George (Courtney B. Vance) and friend, Letitia “Leti” Lewis (Journee Smollett); as their search went on, the trio encountered terrifying things like body-swapping white supremacist cults, terrifying entities, and cosmic monsters right out of Lovecraft’s books.
During its airing, Lovecraft Country received positive reviews and earned Emmy and Golden Globe Award nominations. Unfortunately, although HBO’s Chief Content Officer, Casey Bloys, had stated that creator Misha Green and her team were actively working on the second season, it was canceled only a few months later. The decision was reportedly made due to the show’s high production budget and an alleged toxic work environment fostered by Green.
3
Awake
2012 – 13 Episodes
Police procedurals are a common occurrence on network television. However, in 2012, NBC debuted Awake from creator Kyle Killen and offered a different take on the familiar genre. Procedurals like CSI and Criminal Minds are already captivating enough, but what made Awake stand out was the duality of its premise: Britten existed in two realities, one in which his wife, Hannah (Laura Allen), died in a horrible accident and another in which his son, Rex (Dylan Minnette), had. Throughout the show, Britten navigated both realities, which helped him solve the case he was working on in each episode.
Awake holds a generally favorable reception on Metacritic, as well as an 81% critics’ rating and 78% from the audience on Rotten Tomatoes. Unfortunately, the same highbrow psychological premise that makes Killen’s drama unique also reportedly made it hard for audiences to follow. After Awake premiered with 6.24 million viewers, it dropped to 4.3 million by its second episode. For the rest of its first season, the show maintained such a low viewership that NBC declined to renew it. Thankfully, the news hit the production team before Awake ended, so they could wrap up the story properly, without the usual awkward cliffhanger.
2
Ghosted
2017 – 16 Episodes
After Adam Scott’s success in NBC’s Parks and Recreation, the actor switched networks to Fox, joining The Office star Craig Robinson as leads in Ghosted. The supernatural comedy follows paranormal scientist Max Jennifer (Scott) and ex-police officer Leroy Wright (Robinson), who join a secret government agency to investigate the supernatural. It’s something of a “CSI meets Men in Black” series, as Jennifer and Wright work in a larger team and maintain a buddy-cop chemistry.
Although Scott and Robinson excel as a duo, and some would argue that Ghosted deserves to be revived, there were obstacles larger than their combined talent for the Fox series to overcome. The critical consensus rated Ghosted at a 59% on Rotten Tomatoes (versus the audience’s 71%), and its viewership also dropped following a successful pilot, even after the network brought in Office alum Paul Lieberstein as the new showrunner. Unfortunately, this move shifted the show from a supernatural case-a-week format to a grounded workplace sci-fi comedy, which alienated much of the audience it attracted. Add to that, Fox was also looking to trim the fat of its live-action comedies, and Ghosted was nixed from the network’s lineup.
1
Archive 81
2022 – 8 Episodes
Netflix is notorious for canceling shows, including fan favorites like Daybreak, Mindhunter, and GLOW. Archive 81 was another premature Netflix cancelation; the series is based on a podcast of the same name about an archivist named Dan Turner (Mamoudou Athie) who’s tasked with digitizing videotape and reel records, which were originally documented by Melody Pendras (Dina Shihabi), for the mysterious Virgil Davenport (Martin Donovan). Archive 81 time-jumps between Turner’s perspective in present-day 2022 and Pendras’ in 1994, and reveals that Turner’s employer may be tied to a cult. Not only that, but the deeper Turner delves into the records, the more convinced he is that he could save Pendras from her grim fate.
Despite Archive 81‘s positive reception and hitting Netflix and Nielsen Ratings’ Top 10, the streaming network canceled the show because the viewership wasn’t sufficient to justify its production costs. The cancellation came just a couple of months after the series premiered, which frustrated fans since much of the plot was left unresolved. Unfortunately, there’s not much hope for Archive 81‘s revival, but fans can find closure in its podcast source material, which ran for three seasons and ended in a three-part audio miniseries.
- Release Date
-
2022 – 2022-00-00
- Network
-
Netflix
- Showrunner
-
Rebecca Sonnenshine
- Directors
-
Rebecca Thomas